Thursday, June 28, 2007

Commentary on Partisan Elections

Response to Commentary by Chris Pelly on Partisan Elections:

It’s my party
Partisan elections promote full disclosure
Chris Pelly
Mountain Xpress
06/27/2007


POINT 1. Mr. Pelly states, “In the last six election cycles—all of them nonpartisan elections—not a single third-party candidate was elected to City Council. How could switching to partisan elections make things any worse?”

Who could not answer this question?!

How could switching to partisan elections make things any worse? By making things worse!

With nonpartisan elections, the unaffiliated can freely compete alongside anyone else in the political marketplace. In this open participation in the political process, it matters not that there may be poor support for a third party. What does matter is that the door remain open to anyone who chooses public service. Changing the charter to partisan elections makes things worse by slamming the door on the 27% of unaffiliated in Asheville.

So the question really should be: How do partisan elections in Asheville make things substantially better?

In his ham-fisted attempt to address this question, Mr. Pelly argues in favor of transparency regarding affiliation. But there has been nothing opaque about city elections in the last 13 years. On the contrary, visibility of party affiliation is the one perennial constant in local political races.

Mr. Pelly also introduces circular logic in his main argument in favor of partisan elections. He maintains that the unaffiliated should be marginalized and excluded because they are not popular. But are they unpopular precisely because they are systematically excluded? Chicken - Egg; Egg - Chicken.

POINT 2. Mr. Pelly states, “we do have a self-correcting process: It’s called elections.”

No, Mr. Pelly. We have, in fact, THREE legal and valid democratic methods of so-called "self-correcting": 1) ELECTIONS; 2) REFERENDUM; and, 3) RECALL.

All three of these methods are available to the public for their redress of various grievances; not just the one that Mr. Pelly would draw our attention to. The “Let Asheville Vote” coalition has chosen the second of the two methods: The Referendum. That is our right and the one we will pursue with vigor. Failing that, the other two options -- Elections and Recall -- are certainly still available and can be entertained when appropriate.

POINT 3. Rather than the burden falling on his readers to justify why the charter should NOT be changed to partisan elections, the burden here is entirely on Mr. Pelly to justify why the charter SHOULD be changed. And he most certainly has not done that in these pages.

Friday, June 01, 2007

LTE: Living Wage Folly

Dear Mountain Xpress Editor,

City council wants to include employee wage levels as a factor in negotiating with contractors who bid on municipal contracts. The city would effectively deny bids if contractors were found paying their employees anything below what the Asheville-Buncombe Living Wage Campaign has determined to be a "living wage."

Living wage proponents set that minimum wage level for Asheville at about $9.50 (with benefits) to $10.86 (without benefits). This is based on a formula that assumes, 1) monthly rent costs should not exceed one-third of a person's income, and, 2) that the fair market value for a one-bedroom apartment in the Asheville Metropolitan Statistical Area (which includes portions of Buncombe, Haywood, Henderson and Madison counties) is $534 a month.

In other words, a person's wage should be set at a level that enables that person to comfortably afford a typical apartment in Asheville; among other things that a person might claim to need. That is, employers, under this scheme, should first calculate what their employees need and then adjust their payroll budgets accordingly. But wages should be based on the value of a person's labor to his employer and not based on that person's need to buy stuff. Employees should be paid what they're worth and should have no moral claim on an employer’s presumed duty to make their lives comfortable.

Also, a Chamber of Commerce survey of organizations that contract with the city has revealed that some companies will simply not bid on municipal contracts if the living wage ordinance is passed. This ordinance did pass. And we will have to wonder where those non-living wage employees will be working this summer. Perhaps they could apply for a job with the city, which, happily, already pays living wages to its employees out of the city's taxpayer-funded coffers.

And here is the final absurdity: With the so-called "living wage" initiative, the government is actually putting into practice precisely what has only been alleged of the oil industry; namely, colluding to artificially raise the price of a commodity above market levels; in this case, the price of labor. The government should not be in the business of setting prices for labor -- or for anything else for that matter.

Friday, May 25, 2007

LTE: True Representation

District elections just might work

by Tim Peck
Mountain Xpress
Vol. 13 / Iss. 45
06/06/2007


In his letter to the editor, “Asheville needs true representation” (05/23/2007), Ashton Walton stated that “what’s needed is true representation on City Council of all the citizens of all of Asheville.”

What Mr. Walton laments is the lack of balanced representation from all major areas of the city in local government. In doing so, Mr. Walton seems to be advocating district elections for city council.

District elections would help to ensure greater geographic balance on city council and would give currently under-represented areas some chance of inclusion in decisions that might affect those areas.

But is a district the correct level of political aggregation for seeking representation? And is a district really a homogeneous political entity? I think a good case, perhaps a sufficient case, can be made in the affirmative. But would district elections in Asheville bring to local governance what Mr. Walton is really seeking? – which I believe is greater control over the destiny of smaller, distinct areas.

I too think that the smaller, distinct areas of town should have more influence on matters of governance and should be empowered to grow, develop and change in ways that best suit the people who actually live in them.

This is why I have advocated in the past the concept of the Neighborhood Zoning Authority. This is where established neighborhoods in Asheville would have the authority to develop, implement and enforce their own regulatory standards – within reasonable boundaries set by the city in a federalist model. This decentralization of government enhances democracy at its proper level and puts more control in the hands of those who must live under it.

Certainly the city does not currently have the statutory authority to delegate regulatory powers. This is a problem stemming from the general absence of home rule in North Carolina. The absence of home rule presents Asheville with a great number of problems; from water negotiations to land use planning and much more.

However, Mayor Bellamy, in her State of the City Address, called for greater neighborhood organization and a stronger sense of community within those neighborhoods. This is a good sign and I applaud the mayor’s wisdom and foresight.

And the city has plans now to implement Small Area Zoning as part of its Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) and I think this addition could be a good starting point for recognizing that neighborhoods are unique geopolitical entities that deserve special consideration in the structure and function of local governance.

I believe that the lack of home rule, district representation, and neighborhood autonomy, as well as the cynical drive toward partisanship in municipal elections, reflects a serious disconnect between elected officials and the people who have temporarily loaned them their power.

I agree with Mr. Walton that we truly need a “government of the (whole) people.”

Tuesday, May 22, 2007

Public Comment: Partisan Elections



Public Comment
Asheville City Council
May 22, 2007

City council will be voting on June 12th on a proposal to change the city’s charter to make municipal elections in Asheville partisan elections rather than the nonpartisan elections that we have now. This change, in my view, would have several negative effects. It would:
  1. Disenfranchise third-party candidates by creating process hurdles not imposed on the other two parties;

  2. Discourage unaffiliated citizens from participating in the political process in the first place;

  3. Establish an atmosphere of divisive partisan rivalry over much-needed coalition-building;

  4. Increase the likelihood that uninformed voters can disregard a candidate’s stand on the issues and vote a straight party line ticket; And,

  5. Further lend the appearance of cynical maneuvering to city council’s record.

Of the 56,000 registered voters in Asheville, there are currently 15,000 who are registered as unaffiliated.

This in no way should suggest that unaffiliated voters think alike or represent any kind of unified voting bloc. But the fact remains that this group, the second largest group of voters in Asheville, is comprised of citizens who are not particularly enamored of the two dominant parties. I am speaking of the 27% of voters in Asheville who want nothing to do with either the Democratic or Republican parties that this change would exclusively favor.

My questions are these: Why is this change needed? -- not wanted, but needed. Why now? And what's the hurry?

I believe that city leaders should be cheerfully encouraging participation in the political process rather than devising technical methods for discouraging a large portion of our thoughtful but disillusioned citizens from sharing a place at the table.

Is council sensing in the public mood a desire to make city elections even more partisan than they are now? Or are certain council members sensing the need to ‘circle the wagons.’

It has been amply demonstrated in the past that certain lawmakers, once in office, will attempt to use their legislative powers to ‘stack the deck’ in their own favor in an attempt to retain or advance their hold on power and privilege. In the absence of any really credible evidence to the contrary, I have to think that this is one of those occasions.

As a consequence, a committee opposing partisan elections in Asheville has been formed to carry out the task of securing a valid petition that will force the city to hold a public referendum on this matter. That vote of the public, and not city council’s adoption of this resolution, will determine whether or not this proposed change to the city’s charter will indeed take effect.

Thank you.

RELATED

Public Comment: Matt Mittan, City Council, June 12.



WEBSITES

Let Asheville Vote! website.
Referendum mailing list, Yahoo Groups.

PUBLIC COMMENTARY

"Memorandum to City Council" by Brownie Newman, May 8, 2007.

"Partisan plot" by Eamon Martin, Mountain Xpress, May 16, 2007.

"Partisan elections a way of cutting competition?" by Tim Peck, Asheville Citizen-Times, May 22, 2007. [cached]

"Political parties play vital role in democracy’s nuts and bolts" by Holly Jones, Asheville Citizen-Times, May 27, 2007.

"Partisan plot thickens" by Bert Bass, Mountain Xpress, May 30, 2007.

"Keep political parties out of city council elections" Editorial, Asheville Citizen-Times, June 3, 2007.

"What I learned from Hortense" by George Keller, Mountain Xpress, June 6, 2007.

"City elections could stay non-partisan" by Joel Burgess, Asheville Citizen-Times, June 7, 2007.

"Voters should tell council they’ll make the call on partisan elections" by Editor, Asheville Citizen-Times, June 17, 2007.

"Anti-partisan petition surfaces" by Joel Burgess, Asheville Citizen-Times, June 18, 2007.

"City OKs partisan elections; challenge launched" Asheville Daily Planet, Tuesday, 19 June 2007.

"Machine politics returns to town" Editorial, Asheville Daily Planet, Tuesday, 19 June 2007.

"Council narrowly approves partisan city elections" by Hal L. Millard, Mountain Xpress, Vol. 13 / Iss. 47, 06/20/2007.

"Partying down" by Brian Postelle, Mountain Xpress, Vol. 13 / Iss. 47, 06/20/2007..

The Report Card by Editors, Asheville Citizen-Times, June 25, 2007.

Partisan elections opposed by Joel Burgess, Asheville Citizen-Times, June 26, 2007.

"Partisan elections? Critics make plea for fairness at rally" by Jim Genaro, Asheville Daily Planet, 26 June 2007.

"Grass-roots organizers challenge partisan elections plan for Asheville" by Nelda Holder, Mountain Xpress, 06/27/2007.

"Progressive election policy seems more like oppressive" by Matt Mittan, Mountain Xpress, 06/27/2007.

"City Council Gets Weirder" By Screwie Hoolie, Blog Asheville, June 16, 2007.

"Elections: partisan (yawn) or not?" by Ashe, Ashevegas, June 21, 2007.

"Partisan Voting Controversy Live Blogging" By Screwy Hoolie, June 25th, 2007.

"It’s my party" by Chris Pelly, Mountain Xpress, 06/27/2007.

"Partisan Election Controversy: Long on Rhetoric, Short on Facts" By Screwy Hoolie, June 28th, 2007.

"Wisdom questioned in partisan vote" by Ashton Walton, Mountain Xpress, 07/05/2007.

"Get a vote, Asheville" by Christy Fryar, Mountain Xpress, 07/05/2007.

"Asheville's return to partisan elections" by Jerry Sternberg, Mountain Xpress, 07/05/2007.

"Petition is an opportunity for Asheville to speak loudly" by Charlie Hume, Asheville Citizen-Times, July 6, 2007.

"League of Women Voters supports referendum" By Ruth Christie, Asheville Citizen-Times, July 8, 2007.

"Partisan vote foes halfway to goal" By Joel Burgess, Asheville Citizen-Times, July 10, 2007.

"Council rejects partisan elections referendum" By Joel Burgess, Asheville Citizen-Times, July 12, 2007.

"Voters of Asheville should decide" by Charlie Hume, Asheville Citizen-Times, July 13, 2007.

"Buncombe GOP supports initiative" by George Keller, Asheville Citizen-Times, July 13, 2007.

"Candidate petition numbers finalized" By Joel Burgess, Asheville Citizen-Times, July 15, 2007.

"Public vote push picking up" By Jeffrey Javier, Asheville Citizen-Times, July 16, 2007.

"Partisan critics say petition succeeds" By Joel Burgess, Asheville Citizen-Times, July 17, 2007.

"Public weighs in on partisan elections" by Brian Postelle, Mountain Xpress, 07/16/2007.

"Batting 5,000+" by Brian Postelle, Mountain Xpress, 07/16/2007.

"Critics say referendum petition succeeds" From Staff Reports, Asheville Daily Planet, 17 July 2007.

"The Fabtastic Four" by Asheville Disclaimer, July 18,2007.

"Partisan politics costs vote" by Art Jones, Asheville Citizen-Times, July 20, 2007.

"Press Release: Partisan vs Non-Partisan" by Brownie Newman, BCDems, July 20, 2007.

"Challenge to partisan vote fades" By Clarke Morrison, Asheville Citizen-Times, July 21, 2007.

"Referendum drive may have fallen short" by Jon Elliston, Mountain Xpress, July 21, 2007.

"It ain’t over till it’s over" by Kent Priestley, Mountain Xpress, 07/23/2007.

"Referendum petition needs 39 signatures" By Clarke Morrison, Asheville Citizen-Times, July 24, 2007.

"Won’t forget the feats of electoral tinkering" by Brian May, Asheville Citizen-Times, July 25, 2007.

"Partisan candidates declare" by Hal L. Millard, Mountain Xpress, 07/25/2007

"Brownie Newman’s modest proposal" by Brian Postelle, Mountain Xpress, 07/24/2007.

"Lessons in democracy" by Danny Lack, Mountain Xpress, 07/25/2007.

"Forget the two-letter alphabet" by Tim Green, Mountain Xpress, 07/25/2007.

"Partisan petition too close to call" by Jon Ostendorff, Asheville Citizen-Times, July 26, 2007.

"What would partisan elections mean?" by David Forbes, Mountain Xpress, 07/25/2007.

"Petition appears to fall short" Asheville Daily Planet, Wednesday, 25 July 2007.

"Voters will decide on partisan elections" by Joel Burgess, Asheville Citizen-Times, July 31, 2007.

"Referendum petition succeeds" by David Forbes, Mountain Xpress, 07/31/2007.

"True democracy in action" Editorial, Asheville Citizen-Times, August 5, 2007.

"Next city elections nonpartisan" by David Forbes, Mountain Xpress, 08/08/2007.

"Campaign redux" by Brian Postelle, Mountain Xpress, 08/13/2007.

"Deadline for City Council candidates to file extended" Asheville Daily Planet, 14 August 2007.

"Partisan referendum set for Nov. 6" By Joel Burgess, Asheville Citizen-Times, August 15, 2007.

"November referendum set" By Joel Burgess, Asheville Citizen-Times, August 16, 2007.

CITY COUNCIL MINUTES

City Council Minutes 050807: Resolution to set public hearing on amending charter.

City Council Minutes 052207: Public hearing on ordinance to amend charter.

City Council Minutes 061207: Adoption of resolution to amend charter.

City Council Minutes 071007: Consideration of referendum on partisan elections (pg. 25).

STATUTES, ORDINANCES, ETC.

G.S. 160A-101. Optional Forms of Municipal Government

G.S. 160A-102. Amendment by Ordinance

G.S. 160A-103. Referendum on Charter Amendments by Ordinance

G.S. 160A-104. Initiative petitions for charter amendments

G.S. 160-122. Unaffiliated candidates nominated by petition

G.S. 163-55. Qualifications to vote; exclusion from electoral franchise.

G.S. 163-106. Notices of candidacy; pledge; with whom filed; date for filing; withdrawal

G.S. 163-218. Registration of Notice of Circulation of Petition

G.S. 163-296. Nomination by petition

Sample Charter Amendment Petition (pdf)

Asheville Code: Article XII: Initiative, Referendum, Recall (refresh)


Sunday, May 13, 2007

LTE: Partisan Elections

Dear Editor,

So, according to your article "City moves toward partisan elections" (May 11, 2007), certain members of Asheville's city council would like to make our elections even more partisan than they are now.

The change being considered would require that unaffiliated candidates obtain signatures from 4% of the total electorate (2,249) on a certified petition in 17 days to get on the ballot and would open ballots to straight-ticket voting.

My question is this: Why this, why now and what's the hurry? I have heard a lot of defensive talk from proponents, but I have not heard any satisfactory answers. None.

I can see no other benefit of going back to partisan elections other than to manipulate the law to protect the vulnerable from competition in the political marketplace, to preserve an tenuous ideological monopoly, and shield a governing body from diversity.

Asheville, I think, should be one city that is unafraid of dialogue on a level playing field without the tribalistic patronage of party machinery. City leaders should be cheerfully encouraging participation in the political process rather than cynically devising technical methods for discouraging 27% of our voters from sharing a place at the table.

We can do better than use our positions of power to circle the wagons. We have real work to do. Let's do that instead.

TIM PECK
ASHEVILLE
(Tim Peck is an unaffiliated libertarian running for city council.)

Thursday, May 10, 2007

City Council Race

The Asheville Citizen-Times has published a preview of this year's city council elections and placed my name in the "definitely" column.

Election may refocus Asheville City Council
By Joel Burgess
AC-T
May 10, 2007

Tim Peck, the only newcomer to council elections, is one of many local activists known for opposing development they feel harms neighborhoods.

Peck, 50, of Oteen, is a former Atlanta Coca-Cola employee and small-business consultant. He now works for Wal-Mart. The Libertarian candidate said he worries local quality of life “is being threatened by the reckless big government approach of our current City Council.”

Like Hebb, he wants to reduce of regulations on business. But Peck said he would also push for “stiffer penalties for bad development” and put an emphasis on neighborhood-based zoning decisions.


Here's the text that I sent AC-T reporter Joel Burgess:

My name is Tim Peck. I am running for Asheville City Council. My political philosophy is libertarian in nature. I believe in free markets, limited government and individual rights. I believe that people, not bureaucrats, should be the drivers of a political community.

I am 50 years old and moved to Asheville from Atlanta over three years ago for a better quality of life. I believe that I have found that quality of life here in Western North Carolina.

However, that quality is being threatened by the reckless big government approach of our current city council. I believe that city council has gone off the rails and I am running to provide the citizens of Asheville with an alternative: Less government interference in the marketplace, a business-friendly economic environment, job creation, tax relief, rising market wages (which then means affordable housing), lower barriers to entry for entrepreneurs, respect for personal freedoms, stiffer penalties for bad development, preservation of natural regional assets, greater municipal autonomy through home rule, greater community participation of local government through neighborhood zoning authorities, continuous improvement of the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) and its hard and fast enforcement going forward, and an end to the dictates of special moneyed interests in our community.

With your help and your vote I will work to return Asheville to its promise: The jewel of the state, if not the country. With your help we can finally "let Asheville be Asheville."

Thank you.

Thursday, April 05, 2007

Living Wage Follies

Buncombe could benefit from living wage policies

By Isaac Coleman and Mark Siler
AC-T
April 5, 2007

[...] At $6.15, North Carolina’s minimum wage is $3.21 less than it was in 1968 when the value of the minimum wage, adjusted for inflation, was $9.36. We increasingly live in a country where having a job does not mean basic needs are met. According to the 2005 Hunger and Homelessness Survey carried out by the U.S. Conference of Mayors, 40 percent of adults requesting emergency food assistance and 15 percent of the homeless were employed. In response to these trends, The Asheville Buncombe Living Wage Campaign has been working for more than a year to find creative responses to our growing problem of wage disparity.[more...]

----------------------------------------------------------------------
COUNTER POINT
Of 80 randomly selected individuals who benefited from their ordinance, 58 percent reported an improvement in their housing, 37 percent used the extra income to improve their education, 87.5 percent were better able to reduce their debt and pay their bills, 55 percent were better able to save money.
So the proponents polled the direct beneficiaries and discover that they benefited. Brilliant.
We believe that there is a large pool of consumers, both residents and tourists, who would chose to support living wage businesses if they were identified. This, in turn, would help cover this increased cost to employers.
That would be called the free market, my comrades. If the market sees a value, it will respond by supporting that value. The result is profit. Profit is what makes a business enterprise worthwhile.

The smokescreen of limiting the program to government employees and government contractors is transparent incrementalism.

What the impotent writers are ultimately proposing is using government coercion to interfere in the marketplace and force business-owners and entrepreneurs to directly benefit a limited and diminishing target population of the undeserving at the expense of producers who are providing actual value to society; that is, at their own expense, at the expense of customers who bear the burden of cost-shifting, and at the expense of unskilled workers who will be squeezed out by the artificially-rising cost of doing business.

These writers want the government to do what they are unwilling to do and indeed cannot do themselves: Surmount burdensome, over-regulatory government and prosper in ways that raise wages. They propose a government solution to a government-created problem. Pure genius.

Their goal is really self-serving. It is to pat themselves and their elitist political buddies on the back -- negative consequences to the poor and unskilled common folks be dammed.

Saturday, March 24, 2007

Uncle Earl

Uncle Earl
Grey Eagle Tavern and Music Hall
Asheville, NC
March 23, 2007

Tuesday, March 20, 2007

Milestones on the Road to Hell

Elected officials often claim to favor certain legislation out of a sense of duty, rightness or moral obligation. It is oftener the case that those officials instead favor certain legislation because it in turn promises to keep them in power enjoying the perks, privileges and enrichments that their positions of authority garner for them.

In order to ensure this outcome, elected officials must get re-elected to positions that allow them to manipulate the law. But re-election to powerful political office can be difficult for candidates who respect the Constitution and proper purpose of government; which is to protect individual rights rather than violate them. It is much easier to win re-election by simply supporting and passing legislation that pleases a majority of voters in reckless disregard of its fidelity to our founding principles of individual liberty, free markets and limited government.

Rep. Melanie Wade Goodwin (D) (Montgomery, Richmond), in a recent email, has promised us her vote in favor of a ban on smoking in most private businesses legally defined as “public” – NC House Bill 259, Prohibit Smoking in Public Places. The bill is co-sponsored by local representative Susan Fisher.

The purported purpose of the bill is “to protect the health of individuals in public places and places of employment from the risks related to secondhand smoke.” The actual result of such a bill would be to violate the individual rights of private property owners who choose not to exhibit government-approved behaviors.

Representative Goodwin states that she favors this legislation because she “likes to breathe clean air.” Heaven forbid that Rep. Goodwin should also like to be a naturalist.

And she makes a further incredible and sweeping statement that she would in fact “like to ban smoking entirely.”

Setting aside the blatant totalitarian implications of this position, her immediate concern is that she does not “want to pay for someone else's Medicaid expenses for complications from asthma or emphysema, their lung transplant, or their cancer chemo because they can't afford private pay insurance and they use our Medicaid resources.” And she compares a ban on smoking to requiring seatbelts, saying that “taxpayers should not be required to pay for the results of people's poor choices.”

I agree. Taxpayers should indeed not be required to pay for the results of peoples’ poor choices. However, this is what taxpayers get when they vote for socialism. Taxpayers pay for everything that the government deems desirable to provide. The beneficiaries of this distribution of wealth are seldom those who have produced that wealth. If they were, there would be no reason to confiscate that wealth in the first place. (The moral justification for this mentality stems from a misapprehension of the “general welfare” clause in the U.S. Constitution.)

Rather, and more important, the beneficiaries are more likely to be a poll-tested voting block who can perennially catapult elected officials to office and return them to their positions of granting largess to tax-consumers at the expense of society’s producers while reaping the prestige, perquisites and rewards that redound to their own benefit as a consequence of their retention.

Rep. Goodwin rounds out her argument by stating that “When the people who suffer don't get to make the choice, as in second-hand smoke exposure, their smoke-related illnesses are tragic and needless.”

This is simply untrue. People who suffer are not deprived of their ability to choose among options in the marketplace. Both smokers and non-smokers can make the choice of where to work, dine, or congregate in other ways, of their own free wills without the cloying help of a paternalistic state. The only thing that can stand in their way is the police power of the government; which is precisely what Rep. Goodwin proposes. Rep. Goodwin would force private property owners to cater to her constituency at the expense of their own voluntary choice to cater to someone else.

Rep. Goodwin’s arrogant and condescending good intentions notwithstanding, the House Bill to ban smoking in public places is a heavy-handed and immoral violation of individual liberty. In a free society, individual property owners decide on what their smoking policy will be and allow mature, free adults to voluntarily decide on whether or not to patronize those businesses. If smoking is universally disfavored in society, then those businesses will either suffer or modify their policies.

It is the supreme mark of political cowardice to ignore the sworn duty to uphold the rights of individuals and instead pander to the shifting preferences of a voting block that can help to sustain the officeholder’s position of authority and their subsequent ability to blithely tinker with the lives and liberties of free Americans.

###


REFERENCES:

1. Rep. Melanie Wade Goodwin (D) (Montgomery, Richmond)
http://snipurl.com/1didv

2. NC House Bill 259, Prohibit Smoking in Public Places
http://snipurl.com/1di48

3. Email Correspondence:

From: Melanieg@ncleg.net
To: rhodarmerx15@...
Sent: Sun, 18 Mar 2007 8:07 AM
Subject: RE: HB 259 - Prohibiting Smoking In Public Places

I would love to ban smoking entirely. There are 170 of us in both chambers of the Legislature, however, and I am just one vote. To respond to your point, I am all for freedom of choice, but I don't want to pay for someone else's Medicaid expenses for complications from asthma or emphysema, their lung transplant, or their cancer chemo because they can't afford private pay insurance and they use our Medicaid resources. Limiting smoking is, in my mind, like requiring seatbelts -- taxpayers should not be required to pay for the results of people's poor choices. When the people who suffer don't get to make the choice, as in second-hand smoke exposure, their smoke-related illnesses are tragic and needless.


From: rhodarmerx15@aol.com [mailto:rhodarmerx15@...]
Sent: Fri 3/16/2007 11:58 PM
To: Rep. Melanie Goodwin
Subject: Re: HB 259 - Prohibiting Smoking In Public Places

Then don't go into establishments that allow smoking. That's freedom of choice for the "private" business, and freedom of choice for the individual. I thought Democrats were all for freedom of "choice." Guess not!

I've never smoked, but this bill is insidious in it's governmental heavy handed nature on individual liberties. The reason the government doesn't ban smoking is because they don't want to lose the revenue off the smokers. Oh those tax dollars! How the NC State legislature "loves" this abusive tax system, and the additive nature of endless amounts of "our" tax money. Don't have enough money, just go to the poor old working guy, and pick his pocket. If you, and the other legislators really cared about second hand smoke, you would lobby to ban smoking all together.

Thanks for your response.

Kathy Rhodarmer.


From: Melanieg@ncleg.net
To: rhodarmerx15@...
Sent: Fri, 16 Mar 2007 4:10 PM
Subject: RE: HB 259 - Prohibiting Smoking In Public Places

I'll be supporting this bill. I like to breathe clean air. Thanks for writing to advocate your position.

Melanie


From: rhodarmerx15@aol.com [mailto:rhodarmerx15@...]
Sent: Fri 3/16/2007 3:44 PM
To: Rep. Melanie Goodwin; Rep. Deborah K. Ross; Rep. Paul Stam; Rep. Bonner; Stiller; Rep. Martha Alexander
Subject: HB 259 - Prohibiting Smoking In Public Places

I'm watching this legislation very carefully. And I "Strongly" urge a "NO" vote on this bill, as it infringes on our individual liberties and freedoms. If you wish to make smoking illegal, then do so, but stop with this effort at denying individual persons the liberty and freedom to assemble at consenting "PRIVATE" businesses to indulge in a lawful, legal act of smoking, if they so chose. I'm so sick of the nanny state NC has become!

Are we founded on Socialist, nanny state principles, or on capitalist, free market principles? It's sad to see NC and the nation, move ever farther from the Founders intent.

VOTE "NO" ON THIS BILL!

Kathy Rhodarmer

Thursday, March 15, 2007

CIBO Ad

From: Elaine Lite: "When Mountain Voices Alliance began advocating for policy changes about 7-months ago, they became irate. This is actually the 2nd commercial they did. The first fear-mongering ad was in January and they featured myself and Julie Brandt as "radical extremists" for requesting a legal development moratorium at a County Commissioners meeting."

The tactic that CIBO is using is an interesting one and one that could be favorably exploited.

The first advertisement featured constructions workers toiling away to make a living, a very young girl fearing for her hard-working daddy's future, and a soft-spoken man (Rusty Hunter) hiking serenely through undisturbed woods (who could presumably be her father) with his hound dog at his side while gentle guitar chords are strummed in the background. Closing Tag Line: "Extremism vs. Responsible Growth."

Striking images, all.

However, in the course of building an argument against a moratorium, the narrator claims that, 1) the people who make up the organized resistance to uncontrolled development are a "small group of radical activists demanding extreme development policies," and, 2) that a temporary moratorium will "impede our local economy" and have a "devastating impact on our local economy."

REGARDING CLAIM 1:

The charge of extremism in itself is not entirely negative. It can be argued that uncontrolled and reckless development practices coupled with ineffective legal remedies against property harms could even make my country granny extreme. In other words, even mild-mannered disinterested common folk can be DRIVEN to extremes by unreasonable disregard for environmental and property concerns. Yes, advocating for a moratorium IS extreme. But whose fault is that? Urgently calling for reasonable policy measures to mounting development pressures can be a rational reaction to the real potential for future harms.

But in this case, the charge of extremism in the ad is meant to imply irrationality. It is meant to suggest that those who advocate for a moratorium are a small band of disgruntled environmentalists who are disconnected to the larger community and who would mechanically and thoughtlessly oppose progress, jobs, housing, and prosperity. CIBO would paint MVA as the out-group whose concerns are unworthy of serious attention.

This claim is thin, fallacious, and can be easily refuted with testimonials from a diversity of individuals who are emerging from the background of anonymity and apathy to the foreground of concern and activism.

REGARDING CLAIM 2:

The claim that a temporary and limited development moratorium would devastate the local economy has been severely weakened by precedent. Neighboring Jackson County has moved forward with just such a moratorium. Jackson County commissioners agree with the extremists of Mountain Voices Alliance and do not see the problem the way CIBO sees it. They responded to citizen concerns swiftly and have by contrast placed the Buncombe County commissioner's negligence and dereliction of duty in to high relief.

THIRD, the very fact that CIBO is spending the time and money to counter a "small group of radical activists" contradicts the key message of the ad that these people are insignificant and inconsequential. CIBO must certainly think that MVA is a formidable force that must be reckoned with at the earliest opportunity.

I agree with CIBO: MVA is a problem. Ordinary men and women in this region are being driven to wake up and demand extreme public policy measures in the face of reckless abandon and cascading development complexities which expose the area's bioregion, private property, and local infrastructure and economy to long-term and irreparable harm.